Across energy presentations, versions the following might just be the most common image.
Variations of this image and discussion have been around for decades. This post, while reflecting long-time thinking, was sparked from presentations (such as slide 2) at the excellent Green Growth Knowledge Platform annual conference with much top-notch economic analysis of climate, sustainability, and clean energy/water challenges and opportunities (along with more valuable networking opportunities/interactions).
Bright areas, in short, show higher density + higher economic strength (developed) communities. Brightest areas include Western Europe, Japan, and the East Coast of the United States.
Dark areas are low density and/or low-income economies. Sub-Saharan Africa (notably not South Africa) and
“The World At Night” provides a surrogate to discuss economic development (and, conversely, lack of development). The take-away one is expected to take: dark is bad and we need as much of the world as bright as possible.
There is substantive truth here: the bright areas have electricity, have clean waters supplies, economic and job opportunities, health care infrastructures, higher educational achievement, greater stability, higher life expectancy, and a plethora of other ‘life is better’ measures. (Even if the climate change (and other pollution) impacts are lower in the dark space … which is is used by those fighting climate action as a (false flag) argument against climate mitigation efforts.)
The basic message which we are expected to understand on seeing the image:
- Bright is good.
- Dark requires development to become bright.
There is another way of looking at this image. Very simple, human generated lumens reaching space is waste — no one flips the light switch with the desire to have Martians see them light up their bedroom. While, again, there is truth that ‘light’ represents developed areas, there is also a reality that the light represents a significant opportunity: how can humanity become more efficient in lighting to cut wasted energy lighting the heavens.